I’m stealing this one as well! I’m a thief today… hah. Anyway, I’ll be adding limited commentary, and putting both of your scores in the same rubric, with individual and then averaged scores. Any comments can be PM’ed to me.
Matheson Twins
[Lord Saladin] | [Miehm]
((Commentary))
STORY
~ Continuity ~ [3] | [1.5]
~ Setting ~ [5] | [5.5]
~ Pacing ~ [7] | [7]
CHARACTER
~ Dialogue ~ [4] | [5]
~ Action~ [6.5] | [8]
~ Persona ~ [5] | [5]
WRITING STYLE
~ Technique ~ [4.5] | [4.5]
((Saladin, some of your sentences are quite long winded, and seem rather blunt at times to get to the point. You can use some advanced techniques, even a small metaphor or simile, alongside splitting up those sentences to make it flow better and more interestingly.))
~ Mechanics ~ [8.5] | [8]
~ Clarity ~ [8] | [7.5]
WILD CARD!!! [3] | [2.5]
Total: [54] | [54.5] | [54.25]
Tvier Valka Seula
[Twin Death] | [Exspherius]
((Commentary))
STORY
~ Continuity ~ [2.5] | [2]
((Who the hell is Resheph? Lol. I read over the opening twice and was a little lost both times. Feel free to explain that a little bit better and clearer in the future, so that the reader can get a better picture. Also, in the 10th post you have a lot of unexplained words that are confusing and undoubtedly part of your character’s background.))
~ Setting ~ [6] | [6.5]
~ Pacing ~ [6] | [7]
CHARACTER
~ Dialogue ~ [6] | [5.5]
((It’s hard to follow dialogue when it’s in the middle of paragraphs, especially split up and interspersed. Normally it’s best to make a new paragraph for it, even if the previous and new ones are short.))
~ Action~ [7.5] | [8]
~ Persona ~ [6] | [7]
WRITING STYLE
~ Technique ~ [5] | [5]
~ Mechanics ~ [8.5] | [8]
((One spelling mistake))
~ Clarity ~ [9] | [8]
WILD CARD!!! [3] | [3]
Total: [58.5] | [60.5] | [59.5]
Tvier Valka Seula Advances to round 2!
GAINS/REWARDS!
TwinDeath and Exspherius gain 1878 exp; 200 gold; 2 fate points for advancing
Lord Saladin and Miehm gain 525 exp; 100 gold; no fate points