A Demon’s Arithmetic: Sorry that it seems that a person would start it, and lose interest after a page… only to have another person pick it up and lose interest as well. Those kinda things erk me to no end. But, as many of us have done, we pick up where the thread was left off and soldier on! Good to see you back. I’m going to be giving commentary based on where I see it’s needed. If the Mathemagician or Olivian come back and would like commentary based on their personal additions to the thread they are more than welcome to ask away and I’d be happy to provide such. As it stands, most of my commentary, or lack thereof, is going to be directed at WitW… with a heavy eye aimed at the last couple posts as requested.
Continuity 7
Setting 6
Pacing 6.5
Dialogue 8
Action 6
Persona 6.5
Technique 6
Mechanics 8
Clarity 7
:: Said I wouldn’t say much for those other than WinW, but Math… some of the stuff you wrote went straight over my head. It’s so unique, that explanation on what any of it means – at times – would be muy helpful.
Wild Card 6
:: The last couple posts seemed to be rushed, as if you wanted to get it just out of the way. Though that is to be expected at times, and understood. I’ve done that more than enough times. However, it made the pacing of the thread change, not dramatically, but enough that it was a bit off-setting. Not a whole lot of advanced technique used, probably because the will to just get it out of the way was more important. Gramatically, it was very well written, though there seemed to be at least one run-on sentence that drew away from the pacing and the story itself at times. Other than that, not bad, the rust isn’t thick, lol.
Score: 67
Rewards:
Math: 640 exp | 100 gold
Olivian : 1000 exp | 150 gold
WinW : 2000 exp | 200 gold