Novel Critiques - Are These Feedbacks Valid?

[Flamebird]

Precisely.

The other side is this - everyone is going to have an opinion. That's fine, but the way the opinion is conveyed makes all the difference, and I believe that a few of them on there have shown themselves up.

Yup.

That said, it was posted on Reddit. Expectations for intelligent and constructive feedback were always going to be low.

Lol! I've gotten some good feedback off of Reddit, but that is still true xD

Perhaps you should workshop the writing on here so we can offer a far more constructive and less judgmental appraisal?

That would be fun! I haven't been much interested in RP here as of late to be honest. I've been working more on this original story and LOTR fanfics :P

This site's rules and workshop style has helped me so much though. Submitting my originals works would be fantastic! ... Where do I post them though? xD

[Shinsou Vaan Osiris]

Yup.





Lol! I've gotten some good feedback off of Reddit, but that is still true xD



That would be fun! I haven't been much interested in RP here as of late to be honest. I've been working more on this original story and LOTR fanfics :P

This site's rules and workshop style has helped me so much though. Submitting my originals works would be fantastic! ... Where do I post them though? xD

Obviously our workshop section is mostly for Althanas threads, but I reckon you could stick a new thread up in the FST or Role-Players corner and ask for some feedback. If you like I can do a "judgment" on it, or at least a full bodied critique in that style. It's been a while since I've reviewed anything of yours and I'd love to have a read